Case Study: Two Runners, Same VO2max – Why Economy Won the Race

Share

When two runners have identical aerobic capacity, what determines who's faster? This case study explores how running economy separates performance.

Bob BodilyBob Bodily
5 min readRunning Physiology

Quick Hits

  • VO2max has a 'ceiling effect'—among trained runners, it stops predicting performance
  • Running economy (oxygen cost at submaximal pace) often determines race outcomes
  • Economy can improve 2-8% with targeted training in 6-20 weeks
  • East African runners often excel due to exceptional economy, not just high VO2max
  • Drills, plyometrics, and hill sprints are proven economy improvers
Case Study: Two Runners, Same VO2max – Why Economy Won the Race

Two runners stand at the start line. Lab tests show identical VO2max values. Yet one will finish minutes ahead of the other. What gives?

The answer: running economy.

The Comparison

The Scenario

Runner A:

  • VO2max: 55 ml/kg/min
  • Training: High volume, mostly steady state
  • Race focus: Half marathon
  • Current PR: 1:28

Runner B:

  • VO2max: 55 ml/kg/min (identical to Runner A)
  • Training: Moderate volume with drills and plyometrics
  • Race focus: Half marathon
  • Current PR: 1:22

Six minutes faster with the same aerobic capacity. How?

The Difference: Running Economy

Runner B consumes less oxygen at any given pace. They're more efficient—getting more speed from the same aerobic engine.

If Runner A uses 200 ml O2/kg/km at half marathon pace, and Runner B uses 180 ml O2/kg/km, Runner B can sustain a faster pace at the same relative effort.

Understanding Running Economy

What It Is

Running economy measures how much oxygen you need to run at a specific pace. Think of it like fuel efficiency in a car:

  • VO2max = Engine size (maximum power)
  • Running economy = MPG (how efficiently you use that power)

A Prius and a sports car might have similar engines, but one goes much farther on the same tank.

Why It Matters

At recreational levels, VO2max often correlates with performance—bigger engine, faster running.

But among trained runners, VO2max clusters in a narrow range. The variation that explains performance differences shifts to economy.

Elite marathon runners often have VO2max values between 70-80 ml/kg/min. The range is small. But their economy varies significantly—and this correlates with their race times.

Research Evidence

The University of Exeter Study

In a 2012 study, a group of new runners trained on their own for 10 weeks without any technique instruction.

Result: Despite making no conscious effort to improve their form, they achieved an average improvement of 8.4 percent in running economy, related to subtle changes in biomechanics.

Running itself improves economy. The body naturally finds efficient movement patterns.

The Italian Runner Tracking

An Italian runner named Roberto Veneziani tracked his stride rate and race performance for a full season.

Though he made no conscious effort to increase his stride rate, it increased naturally as he got fitter—and his race times improved correspondingly.

Economy improvements happen automatically with consistent training.

Plyometric Training Study

Research shows significant improvements from plyometric training[^3][^4]. One study showed a 5% improvement in VO2max and a 3% improvement in 3km race performance after just 6 weeks of plyometric training[^4].

Jumping and bounding exercises improved running efficiency—translating directly to faster times. Studies found that 6 weeks of plyometric training improves running economy in trained distance runners through increased musculotendinous stiffness[^3].

Hill Sprint Research

A comprehensive study on hill training found that short hill repetitions of 10-12 seconds led to the greatest improvement in running economy.

Short, explosive efforts develop the power and stiffness that make running more efficient.

What Makes Running Economy Better

Biomechanical Factors

  • Lighter lower limbs: Less mass to swing forward and back
  • Efficient stride: Not overstriding, not shuffling
  • Elastic energy return: Tendons that spring back like rubber bands
  • Vertical oscillation: Not bouncing too much

Neuromuscular Factors

  • Motor unit recruitment: Using the right muscles efficiently
  • Relaxation: Not tensing muscles unnecessarily
  • Coordination: Smooth, automatic movement patterns

Structural Factors

  • Tendon stiffness: Stiffer tendons return more elastic energy
  • Muscle fiber composition: More slow-twitch fibers can be more economical
  • Body proportions: Shorter lower legs relative to thighs may help

How to Improve Your Economy

Proven Methods

1. Plyometrics (6 weeks minimum)

  • Box jumps
  • Bounding
  • Single-leg hops
  • Jump squats

Performed 2-3 sessions per week, running economy can improve in as little as six weeks.

2. Running Drills

  • High knees
  • Butt kicks
  • A-skips, B-skips
  • Cariocas

Running form drills can naturally increase stride length without forcing the issue, leading to faster paces at the same effort level.

3. Short Hill Sprints

  • 8-12 second sprints
  • Full recovery between reps
  • 6-10 repetitions
  • Once or twice per week

The explosive uphill effort develops power and economy.

4. Heavy Strength Training

  • Squats, deadlifts, lunges
  • Heavy loads (≥80% 1RM)
  • Lower volume (3-5 reps)

Research shows strength training with heavy loads has positive effects on running economy and time-trial performance.

5. Consistent Running

The simplest intervention: run consistently for years.

Running at least three times per week (and doing 4-6 runs if you can tolerate it) will naturally make you a fitter runner and improve your running economy.

The Timeline

Neural adaptations take 4-6 weeks minimum. Commit to 8 weeks of economy-focused work, track progress weekly, and trust the process.

The East African Advantage

Why do Kenyan and Ethiopian runners dominate distance running?

While they often have good VO2max values, their running economy is frequently exceptional. Proposed explanations:

  • Running from childhood: Years of running to school develops efficiency
  • Light lower limbs: Biomechanical advantage
  • Altitude training: May improve economy through various mechanisms
  • Natural selection: Generations of runners

The lesson: economy can be developed over a lifetime.

Practical Application

For Recreational Runners

  1. Keep running consistently: Economy improves naturally over years
  2. Add drills after easy runs: 5 minutes, 2-3 times per week
  3. Include short hill sprints: Once per week during base phase
  4. Consider plyometrics: If injury-free and looking for an edge

For Competitive Runners

  1. Structured plyometric program: 2x per week during base/build phases
  2. Regular drills routine: Before quality sessions
  3. Heavy strength training: 2x per week during off-season/base
  4. Hill sprint blocks: 4-6 week cycles

For Masters Runners

Economy often maintains well with age, even as VO2max declines. Focus on:

The Bottom Line

When VO2max is equal, economy determines the race.

The good news: economy is trainable. Through drills, plyometrics, hills, strength training, and simply years of consistent running, you can become a more efficient runner.

A bigger engine helps. But a more efficient engine might be even better.


Improve your running efficiency with targeted training. Use our Running Economy Calculator to estimate your current economy, and track your improvement on your dashboard.

Key Takeaway

When VO2max is similar, running economy determines the winner. Fortunately, economy is trainable—through plyometrics, drills, hills, and simply years of consistent running. The most efficient runner isn't always the one with the biggest engine.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's more important—VO2max or running economy?
Both matter, but at higher performance levels, running economy often becomes more predictive of race times. Two runners with identical VO2max can have very different race performances based on economy differences.
How do you measure running economy?
Running economy is measured as oxygen consumption at a given submaximal pace (ml/kg/km). Lower numbers mean better economy. Lab testing is most accurate, but performance at different paces can indicate relative economy.
Can you improve running economy?
Yes. Research shows 2-8% improvements over 6-20 weeks through plyometrics, strength training, hill sprints, and drills. Consistent running also naturally improves economy over years.
Why do Kenyan and Ethiopian runners dominate distance running?
While they often have good VO2max values, their exceptional running economy is frequently cited. Factors may include: years of running from childhood, biomechanics suited to efficient running, and light lower limbs.

References

  1. Moore, I.S. et al. (2012). Is There an Economical Running Technique? A Review of Modifiable Biomechanical Factors Affecting Running Economy. Sports Medicine, 42(11), 903-921.
  2. Saunders, P.U. et al. (2004). Factors Affecting Running Economy in Trained Distance Runners. Sports Medicine, 34(7), 465-485.
  3. Spurrs, R.W. et al. (2003). The effect of plyometric training on distance running performance. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 89(1), 1-7. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12580657/
  4. Turner, A.M. et al. (2003). Improvement in running economy after 6 weeks of plyometric training. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 17(1), 60-67.

Send to a friend

Know someone training for a race? Share this with their long-run buddy.